American Idol has their top 12 now.  Out of the people who got voted off, the only one who could really sing was Gideon, but he was just so weird.  His voice was great. 

 

Will needed to go just because he sang a James Taylor song.  Kinnick just was too inconsitent.

 

I'm really glad Anya got booted before Melissa McGee, cause Melissa can sing.  I actually really like her voice and her pitch is more consistent than all the other contestants the judges give passes too.  Melissa won't make it far, but I'm glad she at least made it this far so she can go on them American Idol tours. 

 

I just wish Patrick Hall made it to the top 12.

 

Anyone ever notice how incomprehensible Paula Abdul is?  They need to replace her with Peggy Flemming. 

 

By the way... Taylor Hicks is going to win.